6" lens

HOFFMAN@wmich.edu
Fri, 31 Mar 1995 10:20:27 -0400 (EDT)

IMHO -- making a 6" f/15 airspaced doublet is a classic *LARGE* project. At a minimum, it is more than four times the "glass-pushing" of making a 6" mirror, PLUS -- You have to get the radii reasonably (within <1%) exact -- With a mirror, most of us won't quibble over a couple inches in FL -- PLUS you have to get the thickness correct -- PLUS you have to get the surfaces concentric. Not really a good first project. Also, you're right about the cost of the glass -- BK-7 and F-4 cost a LOT more than Pyrex. And if you want to AR coat it -- that'll make aluminizing seem CHEAP. If you look in the back of Sky & Telescope you will see what commercial optikers charge for a 6" doublet versus a 6" mirror -- theres a reason for the diffeerence. Sorry to rain on your parade. Richard Hoffman