[Author Prev][Author Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Author Index][Thread Index]

RE: [APML] Camera Lens Skylight Filters



Hi Eddie,
 
This has been a subject of constant debate among photographers (not just astrophotographers) for years.
 
Shool #1 believes that if you pay top dollar for a very high quality piece of glass, then you do yourself an optical disservice to place another piece of relatively inexpensive glass in front of it.  Your lens is protected more by using a lens hood than with the UV filter, so why put another optical surface in front that the lens was not designed to have?
 
School #2 believes that it is necessary to protect the lens and that, like chicken soup, it can't hurt <g>.  For astro work, of course, you can add in the issue of blue halos.
 
I have always followed School #1 and opted to leave off U/V filters for all my photography, unless they are specifically necessary - e.g. atmospheric haze in a landscape shot.  I do not use them for astrophotography, and have not had any chromatic abberation issues (blue halos).
 
If you do decide to use a U/V haze filter, then I would recommend that you invest in the best quality glass possible.  I use B & W (Schneider) filters exclusively for this purpose.
 
FWIW,
 
Scott

website: 
http://www.rsiphotos.com/ (offline changing servers)
email:  ireland@gate.net
-----Original Message-----
From: owner-astro-photo@seds.org [mailto:owner-astro-photo@seds.org]On Behalf Of Eddie Guscott
Sent: Saturday, June 29, 2002 8:17 PM
To: APML
Subject: [APML] Camera Lens Skylight Filters

Hi All
 
I'm thinking of piggybacking a SLR on my scope to take some wide angle constellation
shots while photographing through the telescope.
 
Most of my lenses have skylight filters attached (mainly to protect the lenses).
 
Should these be removed for astro photography or is it OK to just leave them on.
 
Thanks
Eddie Guscott
 
PS. I'm also getting duplicate messages (only today (Saturday) though
PS. I'm also getting duplicate messages (only today (Saturday) though
PS. I'm also getting duplicate messages (only today (Saturday) though
PS. I'm also getting duplicate messages (only today (Saturday) though
PS. I'm also getting duplicate messages (only today (Saturday) though